Hi @weedor,
Bringing this one back up.
I think that you had a conversation with @Araminta who confirmed that the issue wasn’t with the visibility conditions themselves.
You were applying the template directly from the page editor, which trumps any set of rules set in the conditions modal.
In any case, you can now set templates for specific pages from the Cwicly Themer with 1.2.5.2, which in turn will allow you to specify which pages you don’t want to apply the template.
If there is anything else you need, please don’t hesitate.
Cheers,